5745112/ 5745112-1

Dispute ID: 5745112. CH disputing 4 Debit Unauthorized Transaction from multiple merchants for $237.26. Reg E. No merchant credit found relating to the disputes. No claim cancellation. As per Penny card NOT IN POSSESSION and PIN memorized. Disputed card ending 1867 is closed. Case Decision: VROL Case #: ZD Ticket Number 59116514 for the PVC issued. Waiting for linked dispute to settle. Initial Investigation: Disputed transaction from Wal-Mart Super Center 0585 WAL-SAMS, ROCK HILL, SCUS AND ALBRIGHT ABC 2, ROCK HILL, SCUS are PIN based however there were no PIN failed attempts nor Changes within the disputed timeline.